the tanner ba'

You Choose the 2017-2018 Ross County F.C. Top!

choose-your-own-adventure

Following the lead of many other clubs around the world in letting their supporters have a say in the club’s on-field look Ross County F.C. today revealed three potential home top designs for 2017-2018 and invited feedback from the club’s supporters via Facebook and Twitter.  Before we take a look at the potential tops for next season let’s take a look at why more and more club’s are offering their supporters a say in such matters.

As I see it there are three main reasons for soliciting feedback on matters such as these (clubs have been doing the same thing with badge redesigns as well- more on that in a moment).  First, in the era of the internet people- rightly or wrongly- feel as though they have a right to be heard, and in many cases, “heeded.”  Gone are the days when a club just released a new top and it was “take it or leave it” for supporters.  Second, if a club does release a new top or a crest (remember a few years ago when Everton redesigned theirs?) and the majority- or even a vocal minority-don’t like it, they will never hear the end of it.  This is one case where “any publicity” is not “good publicity,” because…  Third, replica shirts make money.  The more people that like the top, the more people that buy it, the more money that goes into the club’s coffers.  While letting supporters design tops from scratch has rarely gone well for those clubs that have tried it, putting a few ideas in front of supporters and letting them have their say really has no downside.

Alright, with that out of the way lets take a look at what Ross County supporters have to choose from.  I’ll give you a little of my opinion with each and then let you know what the general consensus is among Ross County supporters.

TOP A

Screen Shot 2017-03-16 at 9.13.42 AM

It’s probably not my final choice when all is said and done, but it’s good.  My main objection- and I know I’m the proverbial broken record on this topic- is that there is too much going on.  The gradient effect is good (maybe a little dated) and I don’t mind the white piping, but the red on the shoulder yoke and under the arms seems unnecessary.  If I had to guess, I’d say this would be worn with sold blue shorts (maybe with some white piping) and predominantly blue socks with some sort of gradient effect to mirror the top.

TOP B

 

Screen Shot 2017-03-16 at 9.14.08 AM

This is probably the “safest” of the group, with the only non-standard detail being the sublimated stag’s head behind the club badge.  That’s not a criticism, by the way.  Overall this is a pretty handsome shirt (though I don’t love the “cadet collar”) that could be paired with blue shorts with a red side stripe or red trim around the leg openings, and blue socks with a red cuff or a red stripe on the cuff.

TOP C

Screen Shot 2017-03-16 at 9.13.55 AM

The issue is that I want to “love” it but I only “like” it.  As with Top A I the problem is that there is too much going on.  In this case the issue is that they’re trying to have two shirts in one.  I’d be fine with a solid blue shirt with the striping on the sleeves and sides, it’s a “retro” look that harkens back to the iconic- if unattractive!- Admiral kits that County wore in the late 1970s.  I’d also be fine with it if they’d gone “full tartan,” with the design on the back and front, but they tried to do both and the result is a “good” top that is not a “great” top.  The natural result of this top is blue shorts and socks with red and white details and that might be a bit much.

My final choices are B (as is), A (with a few tweaks), and C (I can’t believe it either).

So that’s what I think, what do the supporters think?

Well, with the sample size between Twitter and Facebook is now approaching 300 votes and I think there is enough data to draw some conclusions.

  • Top B and Top C are currently running neck and neck, with Top A a distant third.
  • If there are any concerns about Top C it is how the tartan will look in person.
  • The only support that Top A is getting is for the collar, which many supporters would like to see moved to Top B or C.

In the end, I think it will be Top B, it has a lot of support, there don’t seem to be many caveats in the comments of those who like it, and most of those who chose Top C and gave a “second place” chose Top B.

Have at it commenters!

Advertisements

2 comments on “You Choose the 2017-2018 Ross County F.C. Top!

  1. Sculptor?!?
    March 16, 2017

    Hmpfh. I don’t have anything nice to say about ‘A’ except that I like the collar, which needs to be moved to ‘B’. ‘C’ is too busy; ditch the tartan or the stripes (and the stripes look all disjointed and not thought out, like someone had extra pinstriping tape and went nuts on a demo model), don’t have both. ‘B’ is uninspired but safe, and that’s the one I’d buy if pressed.

  2. Pingback: WeeFuse’s Adventures in Football: Part Two | the tanner ba'

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: